Which Skin Products, Toothpaste And Deos For Allergies? {Reader Question}




   I got this mail from Ann in my inbox, and I would like to ask you to help me answer it:
    I am hoping that you or someone else might be able to help out. I recently developed some new allergies and after testing I'm at a loss about what toothpaste and moisturizer and deodrant I can use. Every product I've examined contains something I'm allergic to, because I'm not only allergic to the ingredients of drug-store brands but also to many natural and hypo-allergenic products. I went through three different soaps from Denn's before reading about the bar soaps on your blog and trying some of them out.
Allergies:
* Perubalsam
* Dibromdicyanobutan
* Propolis (I guess I can look for vegan products to avoid this)
* Natriumlaurylsulfat
* Cocamidopropylbetain
Additional constraints:
* I don't want anti-perspirant; I've found that causes cysts
* Due to soft teeth, I need fluoride in my toothpaste, so plain baking soda won't work
I'm trying to get help from my dermatologist and pharmacy, but they aren't familiar with a wide range of products.

Hello Ann
  
   For skin care, I love the hypo-allergenic shea butter line from Martina Gebhardt. You can order a bunch of samples through their sites if your Denns doesn't carry this line. I really really love Martina Gebhart's products, so I hope it works for you. Then there is the Lavera Basis Sensitiv line. Otherwise you could try using simple ingredients such as almond meal for cleansing, oil cleansing, and test if the Cattier Micellar Cleanser works for you. You can use oils or butters mixed with hyaluranon or aloe gel to moisturise.

   For deodorant, have you tried the crystal ones? I also like the ones from Waldfüssel (they even have a essential-oil-free version as well). I have also heard good things about Dado Sens Hypersensitiv.
     As for toothpaste, Neo Bio and Lavera both have ones with fluoride, the ingredients are nice and they are not as expensive as many other natural toothpaste. But you might want to try a proper fluoride treatment at the dentist -- they paint on fluoride on your teeth and leave it on there for a while, this is much more effective than toothpaste with fluoride which stays on your teeth for a very short time. 
    I also wanted to talk a bit about other things in your environment that might be stressing your body and triggering your allergies. I'd suggest generally cleaning up your diet and whatever comes into your home, especially removing anything with synthetic fragrance which is a cocktail of undisclosed and barely regulated chemicals -- and a huge triggers of allergies.
   I had a quick look at the chemicals that you are allergic to, and it looks like three of them are often found in cleansing and cleaning products. You might want to take a closer look at the household cleaning products that you use. As household cleansers often don't have the full ingredient list on the label, I'd suggest looking into simple things like vinegar and baking soda and simple household soaps like Kernseife. 
   Be sure to wash all new clothes at least once before you wear them, as brand new clothes often have chemicals from the manufacturing process still on them. Soap nuts are really great for people with allergies.

  Also, allergies are connected to stress and fear, so if there is anything like that going on in your life you might want to add some activities that calm and center you to your day.

   Do you have any recommendations for Ann? Which moisturisers, toothpaste and deo would you suggest she try?

Photo credit: Julia Shashkina

Comments (8)

Loading... Logging you in...
  • Logged in as
I'll certainly take a look at the moisturizer, as my skin is in desperate need with the colder weather. I'm already doing most of the other things you mentioned but it is hard to prevent stress sometimes!
My recent post Tropical Pumpkin Pancakes
Hi Ann, don't panic. You will manage to find something you can use!
Until you find a toothpaste (most difficult thing to find...) you might try cleaning your teeth with some sort of mechanical cleaning agent like
- salt / - calciumcarbonate (for example "Rügener Heilkreide" by CMD) / -xylit.
Most of toothpastes use silica as a mechanical cleaning agent. I have tried them all and find baking soda to be the "most aggressive" and xylit the best for more sensitive teeth. I cannot recommend you a basic toothpaste containing fluoride, but lavera ist producing some toothpastes rather suitable for people with allergies, due to relatively short ingredient lists (see https://www.ecco-verde.de/lavera/neutral-zahngel and https://www.ecco-verde.de/lavera/kinder-zahngel-erdbeer-himbeer for ingredients) (although I cannot use any of them...allergies).

For skincare, you can stick to pure Sheabutter/Coconut Oil/Mangobutter/some other pure plant oil or butter until you find other products you can use. Austrian Brand Mysalisfree has the simplest formulations for people with many allergies. Alternatively you can switch to DIY-cosmetics, which I do and which is acutally a lot fo fun!

As a deodorant you can use baking soda + oils/butters of your choice, which is basically the formulation Waldfussel, Wolkenseifen, Schmidts Deodorants and other baking-soda-deodorant-producers use (plus maybe some filler and some essential oils).
If you do not find anything or have the need to talk to someone who has experience with multiple allergies, don't hesitate to contact me via my facebook site.
thats a daunting task, hard to answer.
Over the past three years I have been on the hunt for soaps etc that don't upset my skin, and here are some things I have found: crystal deodorant is wonderful. The deodorant stick, not the spray, works best for me. Osmia organic black clay facial soap. For hair products I have less constraints so I use the nature's gate shampoo. Since I don't absolutely require fluoride (I do the treatments at the dentist) I use natures gate anise tooth paste which is gentle on the sides of my mouth and doesn't have SLS.

One of the biggest things to consider is the water in your home. If you have hard water and/or live in an arid environment like I do it can be a nightmare as there's nothing that can really fix this. It has caused a host of problems for me and is the reason I need to use all of these special products. Things still aren't perfect, but manageable now with the changes in products.
I just wanted to post an update. I'm very happy with the eye cream from Martina Gebhart. On my face I continue to use Cetaphil. The 'CL med hypoallergen' roll-on deodorant from Rossman works, and Elmex sensitive toothpaste doesn't contain any ingredients I'm allergic to. I'm using Lavera on my lips. I'm using a 5% laurel Aleppo soap from Müller to wash my body, face and hair, and about once a week I also wash my hair with beer shampoo from Lush.

I still need to work out some details on my face routine, as I don't have a toner, scrub, or intensive moisturizer, and my skin is certainly both dryer and more pimple-prone than before. But at least my eyelids are no longer chapped.

Since I mailed the biggest allergic reaction I've had was triggered by undisclosed scents in sanitary pads. That was truly horrible. There is no easy way to tell which ones contain perfumes and which don't; you'd think they'd advertise it if it was such a desirable feature, which is what they told me when I made a complaint about the lack of labeling on the packaging. This was the last push I needed to switch to reusable products.
2 replies · active 468 weeks ago
I'm happy that you found a couple of products that work for you! As a toner you could try pure rosewater -- it has the perfect pH level and soothes the skin. For scrub you could try either a Konjac sponge (for a daily gentle exfolation), or a homemade oatmeal scrub -- again oatmeal is very soothing to the skin.

I'm actually using my Martina Gebhart eye cream with a drop of oil as a face moisturiser because I've run out my regular one and haven't gotten around to buying it yet. Maybe that would work for you?
About two years ago I tried rosewater as a toner. I find the scent refreshing but it did not have a good effect on my skin, which responded by getting blotchy and dry. I don't seem to be doing too badly without toner, aside from having a little more acne than usual.
The only thing you might be bothered about is the greasy feel or smell of coconut oil. But hey! You can easily combat this through putting a shower cap. Let time pass you by so that you will not notice that you have applied the oil to your hair. You will be amazed to see for yourself how your looks like right after one apply. How much more if you apply the oil on a weekly basis or so? Your hair will show dramatic results and your scalp feels good as well.
My recent post Coconut Oil For Hair - Detailed Report about Coconut Oil Your For Hair

Post a new comment

Comments by

Check these out: